The main reason I disagree with this is that it still assumes that Equestria's population is really small, which the show seems to have proven otherwise. For one, 50 guards in "Other" does not nearly account for the cities and towns not listed here, such as Rainbow Falls or other cities that have not been seen but named. Second, the show has stated that Equestria has at least 50 large cities, of which the list includes cities like Manehatten and Canterlot, but NOT towns like Ponyville. Meaning, there at least 50 cities in Equestria that are larger, or likely much larger than Ponyville. Even if Manehatten would still only need 500 guards, that would mean dozens of other locations would need hundreds of guards.
For another thing, why does it even go into matters of population at all? This is a guard write up. To put it simply, I disagree that the writeup implies that Equestria's population is much smaller than what we know from canon.
Last Edit: Aug 11, 2015 15:58:31 GMT -6 by Deleted
The Fun Has Been Doubled! is a My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic moderate-to-advanced forum roleplay. Set after the events of the fifth season, we currently have no overarching plot. Instead, we simply have created the world of Equestria for you as a giant playground to have fun in and to explore the magic of friendship. Canon characters and original characters are available for you to play as, both ponies and non-pony species alike! Just remember that we are account-per-character and we'll be fine!
So why don't you stay for a while, look around, and let us know if we should get a welcome party started for you.